Shortbread Thumbprint Cookies (Three Ways)
I’ve been meaning to make shortbread cookies for two years now. My good intentions have gone unanswered until this weekend when I made these shortbread thumbprint cookies. I figured this year my cookie boxes should finally include them in addition to my annual homemade peppermint marshmallows. I filled these cookies with three different ways; peppermint chocolate, dulce leche and classic cookies.
These are actually the first shortbread cookies I’ve made for the blog. I’ve tried a few recipes here and there but I am always going for the complicated flavored ones. I wanted something simple and classic for these cookies so I went in search for an easy recipe that I can fill with different fillings.
The recipe below is a new creation that combines a few recipes that I found. While researching, I found that shortbread recipes fall into two camps; cornstarch vs. no cornstarch OR extract flavorings vs. no extracts. I tested it both ways and I decided I love the melt-in-your-mouth level of adding cornstarch to the cookie dough and I added a little bit of almond extract to it too. So while this isn’t entirely an elaborate recipe, the simplicity of it makes it possible for you to get creative with your filling.
For my fillings, I went with the classic chocolate kisses drizzled with chocolate ganache.
Dulce Leche filling which will be great with some coarse salt on top.
Finally, peppermint chocolate with chocolate drizzles.
All equally amazing and impossible to pick a favorite. I know the variety will be great for your cookie boxes and if you are anything like me, you are still sending out cookies this week. So add one or three of these to your boxes.
Happy cookie baking!
For the Cookies:
For the filling:
For Peppermint Chocolate Options:
For Dulce Leche Options
For the Kisses Option:
For another whipped short bread cookie recipe, check out these perfect toasted coconut shortbread cookies.
MAKING THIS RECIPE? Share it with us on Instagram using #aclassictwist so we can see what you are baking up in your kitchen!